Most of the gears listed are yes, obsolete in pvm.
Some of the gears listed are bis for pvp.
If this becomes implemented, maybe this will lower the barriers to anyone wanting to try pvp.
On another hand, current perfect enchanted gears will plummet in cost (I am just stating a fact, and that does not mean I am against the suggestion. Just something to keep in mind, that is all).
Edit:
Arguably, victory wings ears are still quite very good for pvm standards.
"Also if it's possible, can you change the Race, Class, and Element enchant on the list to become one?"
So an all prop %?
I agree with Conga, quite a buff. Fact of the matter is, no one in pvm would really consider any of these gears at all (except for mid slots and some I may have overlooked) because we have glacier gears that is very accessible. It just affects pvp, is all.